Is the demoralization of the youth a real thing, or is it being exaggerated?
First, a note: it is possible to prosper in 2026, even as a young person, with the right preparation. But nobody has it, because the institutions where those young people spend 13 years are teaching them nothing — truly nothing — about how to thrive in the 2026 economy.
If they do get advice, it's in the guidance counselor's office, and it's advice that would work great if this were 1957.
Back to our question: the freshest source of polling data I can find is from the fall of this very year — the Harvard Youth Poll, which has been run for over a quarter century by the Kennedy School’s Institute of Politics.
In its survey of Americans aged 18–29, 27 percent expect to be worse off financially than their parents, as opposed to 25 percent who expect to be better off. Those numbers are close, to be sure, but this is the first time in the poll's history that "worse off" has been higher than "better off."
Among college students specifically: in 2003, 74 percent expected to end up better off than their parents. Today that figure is 28 percent.
An important caveat to all this: some of these surveys find young people gloomy about the system itself yet still hopeful about themselves personally. The demoralization is about the institutions and the macro picture.
As someone who grew up in the 1980s, I can attest, as no doubt many readers can as well, that there's been a vibe shift since then. For instance, I remember hearing my late father, a blue-collar worker, discussing his retirement plans when he was in his early 30s (I was born when he was 21), which means he was probably talking about it before then.
He lacked a high school diploma, though he'd get his GED in his 40s. He drove a forklift in a food warehouse. He owned an investment property in a nearby town, and he put in overtime when he could. He had everything planned out.
I don't know this from first-hand experience, but something tells me that if I asked some of the younger folks today about what kind of thought they had given to retirement, they'd look at me like I was crazy. They just want to get through the challenges of the present. They can't even begin to think that far down the road, or start making preparations for it under their current circumstances.
But they (and we) do need to think about it.
There are perfectly fine approaches one might take. A red flag for me, though, is one that assumes the future will be just like the past.
I mean, maybe what worked in the past will work in perpetuity; I can't rule that out. But maybe the past consisted of a unique set of circumstances, and I might instead prefer a plan that doesn't rely on those circumstances, and doesn't depend at all on how well other people's companies (i.e., the stock market) are doing.
Years ago I met the late Austrian School aficionado Nelson Nash, who was a fixture among the attendees at Mises Institute events. He invited me to speak at events of his own. He developed an excellent retirement strategy — it's actually a lifelong tool for financial well-being as opposed to just a retirement plan per se — for people with low risk tolerance, and which has numerous advantages over the usual 401(k) approach (you don't have to wait until you're 59 1/2 to access your money, for one thing).
In turn, Bob Murphy, my friend and former co-host on our dearly departed podcast, Contra Krugman, wrote a whole book about it.
The Bank on Yourself people built upon these foundations, and like CrowdHealth, they're one of my recommended workarounds to help people like us survive in a crazy world. (Implement enough of these workarounds, and life in America becomes almost normal!)
Well, as the old saying goes, the best time to start was 20 years ago, but the second-best time to start is right now. Check them out: